|author||wm4 <wm4@nowhere>||2017-10-10 16:21:01 +0200|
|committer||wm4 <wm4@nowhere>||2017-10-10 16:33:38 +0200|
build: make LGPL mode final (via --enable-gpl)
Rename --enable-preliminary-lgpl2 to --enable-gpl. This concludes the relicensing. Some things are still to do (relicensing some still-GPL optional code), but we consider the code included by --enable-gpl to be fully relicensed. The relicensing was performed by asking every known author for permission for relicensing it to LGPL version 2.1 "or later". If an author could not be contacted or permission could not be obtained, and the contribution was considered relevant for copyright purposes, the affected code was either excluded from LGPL mode (not built), or removed or rewritten. This is the standard in open source relicensing processes. Keep in mind that using LGPL mode is still on the user's own risk. Even though I claim that the relicensing was pretty clean and thorough (measured on the standards of the open source community¹), and I followed the advice of some actual experts, there is still a residual uncertainty due to the fact that I'm not an all-knowing entity (authors could have taken someone else's code and pretend it's their own) nor a lawyer (meaning I might lack associated authority or expertise), and the fact that the judicial system is far from deterministic. The relicensing was performed merely to the best of my knowledge. I reject all responsibility outside of that. This commit also cleans up the "Copyright" file to reflect the finalized relicensing process. ¹ Not to imply that the standards of commercial companies are much higher. Some major tech companies get away with stuff I would not consider clean. See #2033.
Diffstat (limited to 'Copyright')
1 files changed, 24 insertions, 33 deletions
@@ -8,33 +8,27 @@ to know details. C source files without Copyright notice are licensed as
LGPLv2.1+. Also see the list of files with specific licenses below (not all
files can have a standard license header).
-All new contributions must be LGPLv2.1+ licensed, or if the changes are done on
-GPL code, must come with the implicit agreement that the project can relicense
-the code to LGPLv2.1+ at a later point without asking the contributor. (This
-is a safeguard for making potential relicensing of remaining code to LGPLv2.1+
-easier.) Using a more liberal license compatible to LGPLv2.1+ is also ok.
+All new contributions must be LGPLv2.1+ licensed. Using a more liberal license
+compatible to LGPLv2.1+ is also ok.
+If changes are done on GPL code, must come with the implicit agreement that the
+project can relicense the code to LGPLv2.1+ at a later point without asking the
+contributor. This is a safeguard for making potential relicensing of remaining
+GPL code to LGPLv2.1+ easier.
For information about authors and contributors, consult the git log, which
contains the complete SVN and CVS history as well.
-Note that mplayer2 as a whole is licensed under GPLv3+. This is because it uses
-a copy of talloc (part of Samba), which is LGPLv3+, and the next compatible
-license for this mix is GPLv3+.
-MPlayer as a whole is licensed under GPLv2 (incompatible to GPLv3!), because
-some files are licensed to GPLv2 (and _not_ any later version of the license).
-In particular, this affects the file libmpdemux/demux_ty_osd.c. It is disabled
-under mplayer2, and has been removed from mpv.
"v2.1+" in this context means "version 2.1 or later".
Some libraries are GPLv2+ or GPLv3+ only. Building mpv with Samba support makes
-mpv can be built as LGPLv2.1+ with the --enable-preliminary-lgpl2 configure
-option. This is a very new switch and it hasn't been confirmed yet whether
-really all GPL code is excluded (thus preliminary). In addition, it disables
-a number of useful features, some of them quite central:
+mpv can be built as LGPLv2.1+ with the --enable-lgpl configure option. To add
+a LGPL mode to mpv, MPlayer code had to be relicensed from GPLv2+ to LGPLv2.1+
+by asking the MPlayer authors for permission. Since permission could not be
+obtained from everyone, LGPL mode disables the following features, some of
+them quite central:
- no audio filtering, which breaks: --volume, --af, replaygain, pitch
correction, fine control about downmix/upmix/resampling behavior
- Linux X11 video output
@@ -53,19 +47,7 @@ makes this particularly useless for CLI mode, and most of the appeal of LGPL
is for libmpv anyway. Thus it's not recommended to build mpv CLI in LGPL mode
-Source files with specific licenses:
-- etc/input.conf is LGPLv2.1+
-- etc/builtin.conf is LGPLv2.1+
-- etc/encoding-profiles.conf is LGPLv2.1+
-- all mpv icons and derived files are LGPLv2.1+ (mpv-icon-8bit-16x16.png etc.)
-- everything else under etc/ is unknown
-- everything under DOCS/man/ is GPLv2+
-- sub/osd_font.otf is LGPLv2.1+
-- version.sh is LGPLv2+
-- bootstrap.py is unknown (probably GPLv2+ or LGPLv2+)
-- the build system (wscript, waftools/*) is LGPLv2+, some parts BSD
-The following files are still GPL:
+The following files are still GPL only (--enable-lgpl disables them):
audio/filter/* will be replaced with new filter chain
audio/filter/af_format.c mostly LGPL (except af glue code)
@@ -73,7 +55,7 @@ The following files are still GPL:
audio/filter/af_lavfi.c as above
audio/filter/af_scaletempo.c as above
audio/filter/af_rubberband.c as above
- audio/out/ao_alsa.c chaotic history, original author did not decide
+ audio/out/ao_alsa.c chaotic history, one later author did not decide
audio/out/ao_jack.c will stay GPL
audio/out/ao_oss.c will stay GPL
audio/audio.* needed by af code only
@@ -115,8 +97,13 @@ The following files are still GPL:
video/vdpau.c hard (GPL-only parts must be ifdefed)
video/vdpau_mixer.* actual code must be rewritten
+ DOCS/man/ GPLv2+
+ bootstrap.py unknown license, probably GPLv2+ or LGPLv2+
+ etc/mplayer-input.conf unknown license, probably GPLv2+
+ mpv.desktop unknown license, probably GPLv2+
+ etc/restore-old-bindings.conf unkniwn license, probably GPLv2+
-The following files contain some optional GPL code:
+The following files contain some optional GPL code (--enable-lgpl disables it):
input/cmd_list.c potentially some commands
demux/demux_mkv.c some verbose message
@@ -126,3 +113,7 @@ The following files contain some optional GPL code:
player/loadfile.c --frames option (minor but probably fatal)
player/osd.c OSD level 3
player/command.c add/cycle command, possibly sub-add command
+None of the exceptions listed above affect the final binary if it's built as
+LGPL. Linked libraries still can affect the final license (for example if
+FFmpeg was built as GPL).